Why Are People Hesitant to Share Trading Strategies?

In the TradersPost community, a common question is why traders are often reluctant to share their personal strategies. Many users expect to find numerous strategies readily available for them to pick up and use, but this isn’t always the case. There are a few key reasons for this hesitation.

Fear of Strategy Dilution

One of the primary reasons traders hesitate to share strategies is the belief that sharing them will invalidate their edge. Some fear that if too many people start using their strategy, it will lose effectiveness due to market saturation or opposing trades. This concern holds more weight in illiquid markets or niche trading strategies, where a few large trades can significantly impact the market.

Personal Ownership and Ego

Many traders feel a strong sense of ownership over their strategies, often investing significant time in developing and refining them. There’s also an element of ego—traders may believe that their system is unique or superior. This leads to a reluctance to share, as some feel protective of their work, or worry that others might tweak the strategy and achieve better results, causing frustration.

Managing Expectations

Another major reason is the expectations that come with sharing strategies. When a trader shares their system, others may start asking for updates, modifications, or specific performance metrics like win rates and profit factors. This can create pressure, especially when the original trader never intended to act as a portfolio manager or provide continuous support.

Encouragement to Share Solutions, Not Strategies

Instead of sharing entire strategies, some traders prefer to share solutions to specific problems, such as how they manage risk, stop losses, or handle market consolidations. This approach allows for collaboration and learning without the pressure of maintaining a strategy or dealing with its broader implications.

Conclusion

While sharing strategies can foster community and growth, traders often keep their systems private due to concerns about dilution, ego, and the pressure to continuously manage the strategy. However, sharing problem-solving techniques and coding tips remains an effective way for traders to contribute without exposing their full strategy.